Advertisment

Browsing this Thread: 1 Anonymous Users
« 1 (2) 3 »
rewarder rewarder
  • Webmaster
  • Webmaster
  • Joined: 2004/7/5 10:54
  • From Zürich CH
  • Group: Registered Users Webmasters
  • Posts: 3193
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/12 21:11
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #11
Quote:

Dreadlocky wrote:
The only use of such speeds would be faster loading, but yeah no application needs 300K IOPS (maybe something that processes a lot of data in the RAM).


Usually, it is large databases for financial transactions for example that require ultra low latencies.
Dreadlocky Dreadlocky
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Joined: 2013/8/2 12:52
  • From 127.0.0.1
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 61
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/20 15:18
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #12
Yeah, sure. Imagine a bank that fails at speculation because of network latency.

Here's a little video until I get everything next week (except the case): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkHNwNCNFbw So excited !
Dreadlocky Dreadlocky
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Joined: 2013/8/2 12:52
  • From 127.0.0.1
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 61
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/29 22:38
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #13
Alright, so I had some time to spare this weekend and decided to test out the peformance of my new drives.

As you probably know, any decent PCI-E disk controller performs better than an on-board controller (Mr. Marvell, if you are reading this...). This turned out to be true; when we look at the random seeking speeds of the WD2000FYYZ, the 2720SGL clearly provides better results than the on-board controller of the P8B-WS. My Rampage III Extreme's "SATA-3" Marvell controller also scored bad results, compared to the 2720SGL. The two SSDs may be different, but still the KC300 managed to beat the 64GB M4 at almost all stages.

Apart from that, for the sake of this benchmark, I quickly tested a RAID0 array (with Windows's disk management utility and four drives) and it turned out to be impressive: over 600Mo/s in both sequential read and write ! Random seeking speeds also greatly improved, compared to the single drive test.

The 2-drive RAID0 array shows an approximate performance of a RAIDz2 (or RAID6) with four drives. That's the kind of results I should get out of my NAS, for now. This excludes the ARC which is much faster.
Resized Image


Now all I'm waiting for is the case. Once I get it, everything will be at its place and ready to go. From that point I'll start real-world benchmarking (game loading, movie loading speed, media library access speed, etc.).
Edited by rewarder on 2013/12/30 6:49:55
Edited by rewarder on 2013/12/30 6:50:18
Edited by rewarder on 2013/12/30 6:50:27
Edited by rewarder on 2013/12/30 6:50:41
Edited by Dreadlocky on 2013/12/30 9:35:19
Edited by Dreadlocky on 2013/12/30 9:36:59
Edited by Dreadlocky on 2013/12/30 9:37:36
LucaRocchi LucaRocchi
  • Started insulating
  • Started insulating
  • Joined: 2012/8/31 20:29
  • From Milan, IT
  • Group: Registered Users Webmasters
  • Posts: 2228
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/30 14:07
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #14
Very nice table and post
rewarder rewarder
  • Webmaster
  • Webmaster
  • Joined: 2004/7/5 10:54
  • From Zürich CH
  • Group: Registered Users Webmasters
  • Posts: 3193
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/30 15:39
Aw: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #15
Nice work Dreadlocky and very informative table. Maybe we should add some results with the Areca Raid controller we have here ... what do you think?
Dreadlocky Dreadlocky
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Joined: 2013/8/2 12:52
  • From 127.0.0.1
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 61
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/30 16:06
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #16
Thanks guys.

Yes, if you want we can of course add these results to those you already have. That way we have some sort of comparison between the two controllers. I might also add that these results have been made with CrystalDiskMark x64 and one 4GB testfile (4096 bytes sector size).
rewarder rewarder
  • Webmaster
  • Webmaster
  • Joined: 2004/7/5 10:54
  • From Zürich CH
  • Group: Registered Users Webmasters
  • Posts: 3193
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2013/12/31 14:55
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #17
It looks like I have to grab that controller then and run some more benchmarks. Looking forward to do this by the beginning of next week
Dreadlocky Dreadlocky
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Joined: 2013/8/2 12:52
  • From 127.0.0.1
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 61
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2014/1/2 16:25
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #18
Have fun then. ^^

Unfortunately, the card I bought (Rocket 2720SGL, not RocketRAID ...) does not work with FreeBSD and the people over at PC-Ostschweiz (to whom I wish pain, death and eternal suffering by the way) refuse to exchange it with another product. So now I have to sell it and buy another HBA. I guess I will have to use the crappy on-board controller for now.
rewarder rewarder
  • Webmaster
  • Webmaster
  • Joined: 2004/7/5 10:54
  • From Zürich CH
  • Group: Registered Users Webmasters
  • Posts: 3193
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2014/1/6 19:16
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #19
Quote:

Dreadlocky wrote:
Have fun then. ^^

Unfortunately, the card I bought (Rocket 2720SGL, not RocketRAID ...) does not work with FreeBSD and the people over at PC-Ostschweiz (to whom I wish pain, death and eternal suffering by the way) refuse to exchange it with another product. So now I have to sell it and buy another HBA. I guess I will have to use the crappy on-board controller for now.


Compatibility to certain Linux distributions with divers hardware can be a real pain I'm feeling with you!
Dreadlocky Dreadlocky
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Addict to condensation water
  • Joined: 2013/8/2 12:52
  • From 127.0.0.1
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 61
  • Offline
  • Posted on: 2014/1/11 12:01
Re: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage #20
Yeah... At least now I've got it working. Unfortunately, transfer rates seem to be limited at around 100MB/s but I could be wrong. I guess I'll keep games like BFBC2 on my computer.
Aw: The NAS dilemma - a dive into the depths of storage [Storage] - ocaholic